Discernment Counseling for Couples

Discernment counseling is a short-term form of counseling for couples in which one or both partners are uncertain whether to stay together. It differs from couples therapy: its goal is not to solve the relationship's problems, but to help you gain clarity and confidence about the direction you want to take. It typically involves one to five sessions, and is available in person and online.

What Is Discernment Counseling?

Discernment counseling is designed for couples who are not in the same place about the future of the relationship. Often one partner is leaning toward ending it while the other hopes to preserve it. The approach draws on the model developed by William Doherty, PhD, at the University of Minnesota.

Traditional couples therapy assumes that both partners are committed to working on the relationship. Discernment counseling does not make that assumption. Instead, it helps you consider three paths: continuing as things are, moving toward separation or divorce, or committing to a defined period of intensive couples therapy, typically about six months, with divorce set aside.

The aim is not to push you toward a particular outcome. It is to help you make a decision you can feel confident about, whichever path you choose.

When Discernment Counseling May Fit

Different Positions

One partner is leaning toward ending the relationship while the other wants to preserve it.

Uncertainty

One or both partners are unsure and want to understand their options before deciding.

Before Divorce

You are considering divorce but want to feel certain that you have explored every option.

Stalled Counseling

Earlier counseling stopped helping because the two of you were not in the same place.

Children in the Picture

You have children and want to make this decision thoughtfully.

A Defined Process

You want a structured, time-limited process rather than an open-ended commitment.

How Our Approach Works

Clarifying Where You Each Stand

Your therapist learns about the relationship and what each partner hopes for, including any doubts, hopes, and concerns that have been hard to say aloud.

Understanding the Relationship

Your therapist helps you understand how the relationship reached this point, including each partner's contribution, without assigning blame to either of you.

Considering the Three Paths

You weigh continuing as you are, moving toward separation or divorce, or committing to intensive couples therapy with divorce set aside, and what each would mean for you and your family.

Reaching a Decision

The process ends when you have made a decision or understand more clearly what you need in order to make one. Your therapist can then help you begin couples therapy or plan the next steps of a separation.

Core Components of Care

Time-Limited Structure

A defined course of one to five sessions keeps the process focused and prevents it from becoming open-ended.

Individual and Joint Conversations

Time with each partner individually, as well as together, allows each person to speak candidly about their position.

Values-Based Decision Making

Both partners are supported in aligning their decision with their long-term values for themselves and their family.

How This Fits Within Psychology Partners Group

Whichever path you choose, the decision affects the whole family. If you decide to work on the relationship, your therapist can help you move into couples therapy. If you decide to separate, our clinicians can support you and your children through the transition, including child and adolescent therapy and family therapy. With your consent, your therapist can also coordinate with a colleague in individual therapy who is working with either of you.

Your team

Meet our specialists in this area

Emily Bly, PhD

Emily Bly, PhD

CEO, Clinical Director, Licensed Clinical Psychologist

Dr. Bly founded Psychology Partners Group on the idea that people do best when they're matched with the right expertise and feel at ease with their clinician. She works with adults, adolescents, and couples on anxiety, depression, ADHD challenges, relationship strain, and major life transitions, including infertility, adoption, and divorce.

Read full bio →
Eva Leighton, PhD

Eva Leighton, PhD

CFO, Training Director

Dr. Leighton is a licensed clinical psychologist who works with adults, couples, children, and families on trauma recovery, substance use, parenting and behavioral concerns, and relationship difficulties. Her style is warm and supportive, with a natural sense of humor.

Read full bio →
Lorens Hidalgo, LCSW

Lorens Hidalgo, LCSW

Licensed Clinical Social Worker

Lorens is a bilingual therapist who offers care in English and Spanish to adults, adolescents, couples and families dealing with trauma, anxiety, depression, and relationship conflict. Her approach is attachment-focused and psychodynamic.

Read full bio →
Gerard Micera, PsyD

Gerard Micera, PsyD

Licensed Clinical Psychologist

Dr. Micera is a licensed clinical psychologist and performing arts educator who works with children, adolescents, adults, couples, and families on anxiety, depression, and life transitions. His style is warm, humorous, and engaging.

Read full bio →
Jessica Duffy, LCSW

Jessica Duffy, LCSW

Licensed Clinical Social Worker

Jessica is a licensed clinical social worker with twelve years of experience supporting adolescents, adults, couples, and families through anxiety, ADHD, trauma, and family or relationship conflict.

Read full bio →
Megan Sedita, PsyD

Megan Sedita, PsyD

Licensed Clinical Psychologist

Dr. Sedita is a licensed clinical psychologist who works with adults, adolescents, and couples on trauma, anxiety, mood, and relationship difficulties. She trained at the VA Hudson Valley Health Care System, working with Veterans.

Read full bio →
FAQ

Common questions

What is discernment counseling?

It is a short-term form of counseling for couples in which one or both partners are unsure whether to continue the relationship. Its goal is to help you reach a clear, confident decision about the future rather than to resolve the relationship's problems.

How is discernment counseling different from couples therapy?

Couples therapy assumes that both partners are committed to working on the relationship and focuses on improving it. Discernment counseling does not assume a commitment. It focuses on helping you decide whether to continue, separate, or begin a defined period of intensive couples therapy.

How many sessions does discernment counseling take?

It typically involves one to five sessions. Your therapist will discuss how many to expect after the first session.

What are the three paths in discernment counseling?

They are continuing the relationship as it is, moving toward separation or divorce, or committing to a defined period of intensive couples therapy, typically about six months, with divorce set aside.

Does discernment counseling try to save the marriage?

No. Its purpose is clarity, not a particular outcome. Some couples decide to work on the relationship and others decide to separate, and your therapist does not favor either result.

What if one of us has already decided to divorce?

Discernment counseling is not designed for situations in which a partner has already made a firm decision to end the relationship. Individual therapy or support through separation may be a better fit, and a consultation can help determine this.

What happens after discernment counseling?

If you choose to work on the relationship, you may begin couples therapy. If you decide to separate, your therapist can help you plan the transition and connect you with additional support. If you remain undecided, your therapist will discuss next steps with you.

Can we do discernment counseling online?

Yes. Sessions are available in person at our Chappaqua and Hartsdale offices and by secure video.

Is discernment counseling appropriate when there is domestic violence?

Discernment counseling is not recommended when there is ongoing physical abuse or coercive control, and your therapist will screen for this during assessment. If it is a concern, we can help connect you with appropriate resources and individual support.

How do we get started?

Schedule a free consultation. We will talk briefly about what you are looking for and match you with a clinician whose training and style fit your situation.